OK, now that I’ve said all that it’s time for me to contradict pretty much everything I’ve just gone through.
1. Live collaborative performance still has it’s place in recording. For instance, recording a jazz record from the ground up like this probably wouldn’t make sense. Creating guide tracks is a really useful tool, but where the music or musicians are dependant on interaction between each other then the recording process you choose should reflect that.
2. You also have the option to meet in the middle, whereby the band plays along to a pre-programmed click track. That way they can lock into the core tempo while still interacting with each other during the performance. Some would argue this is the happy medium that maintains human performances without unplanned tempo changes.
3. Planning everything out before you come to record a track is great, but you shouldn’t let it hinder creativity or spontaneity. If you have the luxury then by all means, start from scratch and develop new ideas in the studio. But if that flexibility’s not quite within reach, prepare and consider the ideas you’d like to try beforehand. Chances are you’ll still have spontaneous ideas in the moment, but they’ll work themselves in around the prepared ideas you already had earmarked, giving you a much greater chance of landing on ideas you want to keep.
4. Pre-production is by no means a ‘fix-all’ stage of music production. Problems will always arise, opportunities will get missed, and ultimately… nobody’s perfect. But, by following some pre-production steps before making your next record, you might just be setting yourself up for success or at the very least ensuring the process runs more smoothly for you and your producer.